Table 1

Most relevant questions for the ALBINO scenario

% agreementTotalProPPNeoPAx
5.8 ‘I think that I would make the right decision even in this emergency. Therefore, I would prefer to only be informed in a few sentences and to be asked for short (oral) consent before administering the study medication.’55 %54 %60 %50 %
5.9 ‘In the emergency described, I would be glad not to have been asked for permission to give the study medication, because I would have felt helpless and unable to make decisions, and I would probably have followed the advice of the physicians anyway.’43 %
(disagree: 47 %)
40 %
(disagree: 54 %)
34 %
(disagree: 54 %)
57 %
(disagree: 30 %)
5.16 ‘If my child has been given study medication in an emergency without my prior consent, I would decide afterwards as follows (after detailed information):’
  ‘I would agree to participate afterwards.’
  (deferred consent)
48 %40 %43 %67 %
  ‘I would refuse to participate afterwards.’
  (deferred consent)
4 %7 %0 %3 %
  ‘I would have refused to participate before the birth.’
  (prenatal consent)
2 %2 %3 %0 %
 ‘I do not know/ I am not sure for any scenario.’46 %51 %54 %30 %
5.17 ‘I think that giving a study medication in this situation
without my knowledge is so inappropriate that I would take legal action against the investigators.’
8 %14 %0 %10 %
  • PAx, parents of neonates treated for perinatal asphyxia ; PNeo, parents of healthy newborns; ProP, prospective parents.