Table 1

Overall characteristics of included studies

Study characteristics
 Number of patients enrolled49 (35–59)
 Single centre31 (89)
 Gestational age (weeks)26.1–32.8
 Birth weight (g)784–1934
 Day of life at time of study2–15
 Study design
  Randomised controlled trial12 (34)
  Prospective observational22 (63)
  Retrospective1 (3)
Assessment of extubation readiness
 Duration of assessment
  <3 min7 (20)
  3–10 min14 (40)
  30 min–2 hours8 (23)
  4–24 hours4 (11)
  Not specified2 (6)
 Level of PEEP used
  Zero6 (17)
  2–4 cmH2O9 (26)
  5–6 cmH2O5 (14)
  Combination of two levels of PEEP2 (6)
  Not specified13 (37)
Outcome: extubation success
 Primary definition used
  No reintubation26 (74)
  No resumption of invasive MV4 (11)
  No reintubation or institution of CPAP5 (14)
 Time frame used for primary definition
  Anytime1 (3)
  ≤24 hours6 (17)
  48 hours15 (43)
  72 hours11 (31)
  120 hours1 (3)
  Not specified1 (3)
  • Values are expressed as median (IQR), n (%) or range.

  • CPAP, continuous positive airway pressure; MV, mechanical ventilation; PEEP, positive end-expiratory pressure.