Table 1

Composite scores of SIBs tested sorted by a priori category pass and %CV

A priori categoriesMinimum delivered tidal volume*
(a)
Batch test variance (n)
(b)
High PIP fail
(c)
Start distance§
(d)
Category pass/fail
Model (n=units)
Part no
Type RU/SU
Mean volume¶% CV mean of distances¶% of inflations>45 cm H2Omma, b, c, d
1. Laerdal (10) 845031 SU4.97.00.725✓✓✓✓
2. Portex (9) 8527MPB SU4.17.7025✓✓✓✓
3. Galemed (10) SHMC 2203 SU3.98.6025✓✓✓✓
4. Vital signs (10) 7902R SU3.29.0020✓✓✓✓
5. Laerdal (10) 8560533 Vertical RU3.89.0020✓✓✓✓
6. Laerdal (10) 850050 RU3.19.3020✓✓✓✓
7. Ambu (10) SPUR II SU2.510.2015✓✓✓✓
8. Portex (9) 8528M SU3.211.0025✓✓✓✓
9. Portex (9) 8527MP SU3.212.3025✓✓✓✓
10. Headstar (10) HP9333FN SU4.020.50.125✓✓✓✓
11. Besmed (11) BE-1703 SU3.19.77.120✓✓✗✓
12. Mercury (4) 1055299 SU3.610.76.420✓✓✗✓
13. Hsiner (10) PH60103 SU3.112.27.720✓✓✗✓
14. Hsiner (7) 60152 SU3.215.34.620✓✓✗✓
15. Hsiner (10) 60 113 P SU2.948.9030✓✗✓✓
16. Hudson RCI (9) 5364 SU8.87.1040✗✓✓✗
17. Besmed (10) BE-2701 SU2.734.2040✓✗✓✗
18. Hsiner (5) 60113 SU3.446.42.930✓✗✗✓
19. Zeal (5) RSB 1001 RU2.547.33.730✓✗✗✓
20. Meditrin (5) Infant 250 mL RU6.337.2040✗✗✓✗
  • *Pass criteria; deliver minimum usable volume of 2.5–5 mL.

  • †Pass criteria; average CV of delivered volume <30% (all distances).

  • ‡Pass criteria; <1% of inflations>45 cm H2O.

  • §Pass criteria; average start distance 50% (≤30 mm) of total compression distance.

  • ¶Tidal volumes and CV all significantly different ANOVA repeated measures, p<0.001.

  • ANOVA, analysis of variance; CV, coefficient of variation; RU, reusable; SIB, self-inflating bags; SU, single use.