Table 1

Reasons for offering cooling therapy or not for babies with mild neonatal encephalopathy (NE)

Units offering cooling therapy in mild NE (multiple selections possible) 36 (75%)
Risk of long-term adverse neurological problems17 (47%)
It is very difficult to grade NE soon after birth25 (69%)
Mild NE may progress to moderate NE, missing the window period of cooling28 (78%)
Litigation risks if baby is not offered cooling and later develops neurological deficits8 (22%)
Cooling therapy is extremely safe and easy to provide12 (33%)
Other*8 (22%)
Units not offering cooling therapy in mild NE (multiple selections possible) 12 (25%)
The vast majority of babies with mild NE do well and do not get any neurological deficit7 (58%)
There is no evidence to support cooling in babies with mild NE12 (100%)
Cooling therapy is not without side effects5 (42%)
Avoiding additional interventions (ventilation/sedation) or prolonged hospitalisation3 (25%)
  • Other reasons reported were: those with abnormal aEEG may benefit (three responses); based on clinical experience (one response), colleague/network advice (one response). Three units gave unclear answers.