AIM To identify causes of preterm delivery and intrauterine growth retardation (IUGR) in a malaria endemic region of Papua New Guinea.
METHODS Independent predictors of preterm delivery and birthweight in term infants were identified using multiple regression analysis in a prospective study of 987 singleton live births delivered in Madang Hospital.
RESULTS Overall, Plasmodium falciparum infection of the placenta was associated with a reduction in birthweight of 130 g. Malaria was significantly more common in primigravidae than multigravidae and probably contributed to both preterm delivery and IUGR. Maternal haemoglobin concentrations were significantly lower in malaria infected than non-infected women and reduced haemoglobin was the main determinant of preterm delivery. Poorer maternal nutritional status and smoking were associated with both prematurity and IUGR. Greater antenatal clinic attendance predicted increased birthweight in term infants.
CONCLUSIONS Protection against malaria during pregnancy, especially in primigravidae, improved nutrition in women and discouragement of smoking would probably reduce both preterm delivery and IUGR. Greater use of existing antenatal clinics might increase birthweight in term infants.
In coastal Papua New Guinea, roughly a third of low birthweight infants were preterm and two thirds were growth retarded, term infants
Protection from malaria during pregnancy, especially in primigravidae, may prevent both IUGR and preterm delivery
A reduced maternal haemoglobin concentration was the main determinant of preterm birth
Prevention of smoking during pregnancy, improved nutrition in girls and women, and increased antenatal care may also prevent low birthweight in this region
- intrauterine growth retardation
- Papua New Guinea
- antenatal care
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Low birthweight complicates around 17% of all births1 and is the major risk factor for mortality in early infancy.2-3 Around 90% of all low birthweight infants are born in developing countries,1 mostly caused by intrauterine growth retardation (IUGR) rather than prematurity.4 5 Studies undertaken in Papua New Guinea have shown that acute diarrhoea6 and mortality from measles7 were significantly higher among low birthweight than among normal infants. Malarial infection during pregnancy is an important, and potentially preventable, environmental cause of low birthweight. The detrimental effects occur mainly in primigravidae as immunity develops during the first pregnancy and reduces infection in subsequent pregnancies.8 Although most studies have not accounted for preterm delivery in the aetiology of low birthweight, malaria is generally thought to cause it through intrauterine growth retardation rather than prematurity.9-10 The differentiation between these two mechanisms is important because the causes and outcomes of each differ. For example, neonatal mortality in preterm compared with IUGR infants was double in urban Brazil11 and nine times as high in Malawi.12
During studies on the relation between α+thalassaemia and malaria, we undertook a prospective study of singleton live births delivered at Madang Hospital on the north coast of Papua New Guinea where transmission of Plasmodium falciparum is hyperendemic and perennial.13 This provided an opportunity to identify socioeconomic and biological factors that were associated with IUGR and preterm delivery. Review of the hospital records for 1995 showed a total of 2173 deliveries of whom 315 (14.5%) had not received any antenatal care. Seventy three stillbirths (3.4%) and five maternal deaths were recorded (S Allen; unpublished data).
Permission was obtained from the Medical Research Advisory Committee of Papua New Guinea and informed consent was obtained from all mothers participating in the study. Women with live singleton infants, who had lived in Madang Province throughout their pregnancy, were recruited within 24 hours of delivery. As the detrimental effects of malaria are known to be greatest in primigravidae,8 a roughly equal number of women in each of three gravida groups (gravida 1, 2, and ⩾3) was obtained by recruiting all primigravidae and gravida 2 women, and the gravida ⩾3 women delivering immediately after each primigravida. Recruitment took place during weekdays on a 24 hour basis. Ethnicity was categorised according to the region of origin of the local language spoken by the mother. In Madang Province, rural villages are mainly inhabited by Papua New Guineans of Madang ethnicity, whereas people from all regions of the country live in periurban settlements and town. The occupation of the mother and of the infant’s father was categorised as either unpaid (which included subsistence farming and unemployed), paid unskilled work, or paid skilled work (defined as any occupation requiring literacy).
Women attended one of several district antenatal clinics during pregnancy which dispensed chloroquine and iron and folate tablets and encouraged them to attend Madang Hospital for delivery. The first measurement of maternal weight and haemoglobin, the total number of clinic visits, and obstetric and medical history were recorded from clinic cards when available. Standing height was measured after delivery with a wall mounted ruler when the mother could stand comfortably. Body mass index was calculated from a clinic weight recorded ⩽28 weeks gestation and height after delivery.
Infants were weighed at birth to the nearest 10 g on electronic scales (Seca, UK) by the nursing attendants and were examined by the project physician (SA) within 24 hours of delivery. Gestation was assessed by a rapid score14 and a Dubowitz assessment15performed if the rapid score was <7 (equivalent to <38.5 weeks) or if the birthweight was <2500 g. Infants in whom a specific cause of abnormal intrauterine growth was suspected were excluded (gestational diabetes or hypertension, major congenital abnormality). Prematurity was defined as a Dubowitz score of <45 (equivalent to <37 weeks gestation) and IUGR as low birthweight among term infants. IUGR among preterm infants was not considered, due to a lack of birthweight standards in this population and accurate gestational age based on ultrasound examination.
A blood count (MD8, Coulter Electronics, UK) was performed and blood films prepared from maternal venous blood. The number of P falciparum parasites per 200 white blood cells was counted in thick films and parasite density calculated from the measured white cell count. Thick and thin blood films were made from the cut maternal surface of the placenta and parasite density was calculated from the number of parasites per 100 high power fields, assuming that each field contains 0.002 μl of blood.
Continuous variables tended to have skewed distributions and, therefore, median values with the interquartile range (IQR) are quoted. Two main analyses were performed. Determinants of preterm delivery were investigated using logistic regression analysis in all infants with gestation (preterm <37 weeks or term ⩾37 weeks) as the dependent variable. All infants delivered ⩾28 weeks gestation and, therefore, only information relating to antenatal clinic visits ⩽28 weeks gestation was included in the analysis. Determinants of birthweight in term infants were investigated using multiple regression analysis. For both analyses, forward stepwise regression analysis was performed to identify factors which independently predicted the outcome variable.
Nine hundred and eighty seven singleton live born infants were recruited between July 1994 and January 1996. Birthweight in preterm infants ranged from 0.78 to 3.00 kg and 59/62 (95%) were low birthweight. Overall, the relative risk (95% confidence interval) of low birthweight for primigravidae compared with gravida 2 women was 2.23 (1.43–3.50), p<0.001, and compared with all multigravidae it was 2.83 (2.00–4.01), p<0.0001. BMI was calculated in 466 women and 29 (6.2%) were underweight (<20 kg/m2). BMI was strongly correlated with weight during pregnancy (Pearson’s r=0.91; 95% CI 0.89–0.92), but weakly correlated with height (r=0.09; 95% CI 0.01–0.17).
The prevalence of prematurity, IUGR, and malaria infection of both the placenta and maternal blood at delivery were significantly higher in primigravidae than multigravidae (table 1). Although numbers were small, no evidence of a decrease in birthweight or increase in preterm deliveries was observed in gravida ⩾6. Median (IQR) birthweight was 2.85 kg (2.50–3.10) when the placenta was infected, and when not, 2.98 kg (2.67–3.27; p<0.0001). Median maternal haemoglobin after delivery when the placenta was infected measured 101 g/l (91–110) and when not 107 g/l (94–118; p<0.001). Median maternal haemoglobin after delivery was similar in each gravida group, although there was a tendency for more primigravidae than multigravidae to have haemoglobin values <100 g/l (41.6 vs 35.9%; p=0.10). Placental infection was highly correlated with maternal peripheral blood infection (p<0.001) and the differences in birthweight and maternal haemoglobin were similar if maternal infection rather than placental infection was analysed. Haemoglobin during pregnancy tended to decline as gestation increased (n=392; r= -0.10 (95% CI −0.20 to 0.00). Haemoglobin values during pregnancy cannot be compared with values after delivery as different methods of measurement were used.
The prevalence of placental and maternal peripheral blood parasitaemia was similar in those who had and had not taken chloroquine during pregnancy (186/791 (23.5%) vs20/68 (29.4%), p=0.35 and 167/900 (18.6%)vs 15/76 (19.7%), p=0.92, respectively). The density of parasitaemia in each site was not related to chloroquine prophylaxis. However, median (IQR) maternal haemoglobin concentrations after delivery were significantly greater in women who gave a history of chloroquine prophylaxis (n=862, 105 g/l (93–117)) than in those who did not (n=61, 99 g/l (82–107); p=0.0002). The usage of chloroquine and iron/folate was highly correlated (p<0.001) and similar differences in haemoglobin concentrations were observed if iron/folate rather than chloroquine usage was analysed.
DETERMINANTS OF PRETERM DELIVERY AND BIRTHWEIGHT IN TERM INFANTS
In univariate analysis both preterm delivery and IUGR were significantly associated with lower BMI, lower gravidity, the mother smoking during pregnancy, and working in a garden (table 2). Paternal employment in skilled work was negatively associated with prematurity and IUGR. Other predictors of prematurity were reduced maternal haemoglobin both during and after pregnancy and no chloroquine and iron/folate. Gestation (beyond 37 weeks) had the strongest association with birthweight in term infants (table 2) (fig 1). The mother or father in paid employment, greater maternal height, and a greater number of antenatal clinic visits were associated with increased birthweight in term infants whereas malaria infection at delivery were associated with IUGR. Maternal age was not significantly associated with birthweight when gravidity was included as a confounder. Only haemoglobin measured ⩽28 weeks gestation were included in the analysis of haemoglobin during pregnancy and these measurements had been performed at a similar gestation in preterm and term infants (median 22.5 and 23.0 weeks, respectively; p=0.62). The gestation at which maternal weight had been measured was also similar for preterm and term infants (median 22.9 and 20.9 weeks respectively; p=0.22). Median (IQR) birthweight was significantly greater in boys (2.99 kg (1.31–4.66) than girls (2.90 (1.90–4.22); p=0.0076).
Birthweight was greater in the infants of women living in Madang town (median (IQR) 3.03 kg (2.69–3.36)) than in rural villages (2.88 (2.54–3.20)) or settlements (2.92 (2.63–3.24); p<0.001), but residence was not related to gestation (p=0.86). Birthweight was greater in the infants of Highland women (3.18 kg (2.76–3.49)) than all other women (p=0.011; other coastal regions 3.03 (2.70–3.38), Madang 2.89 (2.56–3.18), and Sepik 2.90 (2.62–3.21)). A greater proportion of Highland women lived in town (15, 47%) vs190 (21%), respectively; p=0.001) and a lower proportion had worked in gardens (13, 34%) vs 500 (53%), respectively; p=0.024). Median (IQR) gestation in women of Highland ethnicity was 39 (39–40) weeks and was similar to that in all other women (39 (38–40); p=0.22). Highland women had greater haemoglobin concentrations both during pregnancy and after delivery than other women—for example, median (IQR) haemoglobin after delivery 115 g/l (94–127) vs 105 g/l (92–116), respectively; p=0.001. Smoking was more common among Highland women, but all other factors, including anthropometric measurements and parasitological indices, were similar.
Variables with an independent and significant association with prematurity identified by forward stepwise logistic regression analyses (excluding BMI) are shown in table 3. When only the 466 records with a value for BMI were analysed, only maternal haemoglobin after delivery (OR=0.96, 95% CI 0.94–0.99; p=0.005) and BMI (OR=0.84, 95% CI 0.70–1.01; p=0.042) were significantly predictive of preterm delivery. Similarly, factors independently associated with birthweight are shown in table 4. The same factors were identified when BMI was omitted from the analysis and women without a BMI value were included. In multigravidae a previous miscarriage or stillbirth was also independently associated with birthweight (β=−127 g; 95% CI−222 to−31; p=0.009).
Assessment of the impact of malaria on the outcome of pregnancy is complicated because the greatest incidence of infection occurs during the second trimester, and placental and peripheral blood parasitaemia may have resolved by the time of delivery.8 This may account for the apparent absence of an effect of malaria infection at delivery on birthweight in a small study of hospital deliveries in the Sepik region of Papua New Guinea.16 Malaria is an environmental factor which affects primigravidae more than multigravidae and the risk of low birthweight among primigravidae relative to multigravidae may reflect more accurately the impact of malaria during pregnancy than the presence of either placental or maternal peripheral blood parasitaemia at delivery.17 Both malaria infection at delivery and low birthweight were greatly increased in primigravidae compared with multigravidae in this study and this pattern is similar to that reported in African women.8 Overall, malaria infection of the placenta was associated with a reduction in birthweight of 130 g—a difference similar to that found in Africa8 and Thailand.18 Low gravidity was an independent predictor of both preterm delivery and IUGR in multiple regression analysis, suggesting that malaria infection contributed to both outcomes.
In contrast to developed countries, neonatal mortality in preterm infants in developing countries remains high11 19 and has been reported to be much higher in preterm than growth retarded infants.11 12 Although acute malaria has been observed to cause preterm labour,20 21 the few epidemiological studies which have considered malaria as a cause of prematurity have produced conflicting results. Maternal infection was not associated with preterm delivery in Thailand19 or in a small study in the Sepik region of Papua New Guinea.22 Although gestational age was not related to either placental or maternal parasitaemia at delivery in the Ivory Coast, maternal antibody titres against P falciparum were significantly higher in mothers of preterm than term infants.10 Placental and cord blood parasitaemia were more common in preterm than term infants in Malawi,23 and parasitaemia and maternal anaemia were associated with preterm delivery in Mozambique.24
In this study a third of all low birthweight infants were preterm and reduced maternal haemoglobin after delivery was the factor most strongly predictive of preterm delivery. Malaria is a major cause of maternal anaemia in this region and the highest rate of preterm deliveries occurred among anaemic women in a previous study in Madang.25 Hookworm infection, although common, does not cause anaemia in this population because worm burdens are low.26 Homozygous α+-thalassaemia is common in this population and, although associated with mild anaemia, it prevents severe malarial anaemia in children.27 The impact of α+-thalassaemia on maternal anaemia and the outcome of pregnancy will be reported separately.
The prevention of malaria increased maternal haemoglobin concentrations in several studies.28 Chloroquine prophylaxis increased haemoglobin in this study and in the previous study of Madang women.25 The finding that chloroquine prophylaxis was a significant independent predictor of delivery at term needs to be interpreted with caution as women delivering at term would have had greater opportunity to take this drug than those delivering before term. As observed before,29 chloroquine did not reduce either placental or maternal peripheral blood infection at delivery. The choice of an alternative antimalarial drug to chloroquine depends on several factors, and randomised control trials assessing various regimens have been reviewed recently.28 Additional strategies to prevent malaria during pregnancy, such as insecticide impregnated bed nets,30 and the targeting of interventions to primigravidae, should also be considered.
Poor maternal nutritional status was reported to be associated with reduced birthweight in previous studies in the Highlands31and coastal regions of Papua New Guinea.32 33 In this study lower BMI was an independent predictor of both preterm delivery and IUGR and lower maternal height were also independently associated with IUGR. BMI serves as a measure of chronic energy deficiency and, as expected, was highly correlated with maternal weight but not height.34 Maternal malnutrition was probably underestimated in this study because BMI was calculated from weight measured during pregnancy rather than from pre-pregnancy weight which would be expected to be lower. Low maternal height is a consequence of growth failure during childhood and adolescence.
Gestation was the strongest predictor of increased birthweight in term infants and this suggests that interventions which prolong gestation may increase birthweight in term infants as well as reduce preterm delivery. Greater birthweight among Highland women delivering on the coast than indigenous coastal mothers has been noted before and considered to be due, in part, to longer gestation.31 32Gestation at delivery was not related to ethnic origin in this study and better intrauterine growth in Highland women was likely to be a consequence of their more favourable economic status. Around 70% of women living in Madang villages receive at least some antenatal care.25 Antenatal clinic attendance was negatively associated with IUGR and this association was independent of chloroquine prophylaxis and markers of family wealth. Previous studies have shown increased perinatal mortality among infants of women who do not receive any antenatal care32 and lower average birthweight in village than hospital deliveries.22 Smoking has been identified as the most important single cause of low birth weight in developed countries9 and was significantly and independently associated with both preterm delivery and IUGR in this study.
In summary, we have identified several determinants of prematurity and IUGR which could be modified by community health services in Madang Province in an attempt to reduce infant mortality. Integrated antenatal care should be promoted and focus on effective measures to prevent malaria, especially important in primigravidae and for the prevention of pregnancy anaemia. Improving nutritional status in girls and young women, and during pregnancy, and discouraging smoking, would also be expected to prevent low birthweight in this population.
We are indebted to women delivering in the “haus karim” of Madang hospital for their participation, the ward nursing staff, Willie Deppsone for help with recruitment and Dr Michael Alpers for helpful guidance.
This project is part of a multicentre study of the effects of haemoglobin and red cell genetic variants on malaria in the South Pacific region and was funded by The Wellcome Trust grant No 035893.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.