Abstract
Objective
To assess the reliability of estimates of static respiratory system compliance (Crs) made by junior hospital doctors caring for ventilated newborn infants.
Design
A prospective comparison of junior doctors' estimates of Crs to the Crs measured immediately afterwards
Setting
A regional neonatal intensive care nursery in Edinburgh, Scotland.
Patients
46 ventilated newborn infants.
Measurements and results
Crs was estimated by three grades of junior doctor (Senior House Officer, Registrar and Research Fellow) using two different methods, (i) based on visual assessment of tidal volume in relation to inflation pressure (optical Crs) and (ii) directly using a visual analogue scale (analogue Crs). The Crs was then measured immediately afterwards using the single breath passive expiratory flow technique. The differences between the estimates and the measurements were calculated for each grade of observer and plotted against the corresponding measurements. The relationship between estimates and measurements was also expressed in terms of the coefficients of determinationr 2 calculated by least squares regression. With both methods of estimation observers tended to overestimate the Crs of infants with lower measured Crs and underestimate that of infants with higher measured Crs with many estimates differing from the measurements by more than 50%. Values ofr 2 ranged from 0.086 to 0.481 indicating a weak relationship between the estimates and the measurements
Conclusions
Junior doctors' estimates of Crs were unreliable and did not represent a useful method of assessing respiratory function. The clinical use of compliance measurements merits wider evaluation.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aufricht C, Kohlhauser C, Simbruner G (1990) Comparison of bedside methods to assess lung mechanics in ventilated neonates: inflation pressure, amount of ventilation and optical compliance versus measured compliance. Wien Klin Wochenschr 102:307–309
Aufricht C, Huemer C, Frenzel C, Simbruner G (1993) Respiratory compliance assessed from chest expansion and inflation pressure in ventilated neonates. Am J Perinatol 10:139–142
Morrison SC (1988) Radiologic findings of newborn respiratory diseases. In: Carlo WA, Chatburn RL (eds) Neonatal Respiratory Care, 2nd ed. Year Book Medical Publishers, Chicago, pp 289–319
Tarnow-Mordi W, Wilkie R, Reid E (1994) Static respiratory compliance in the newborn I: A clinical and prognostic index for mechnically ventilated infants. Arch Dis Child 70:F11-F15
Wilkie RA, Bryan MH, Tarnow-Mordi WO (1994) Static respiratory compliance in the newborn II: its potential for improving the selection of infants for early surfactant therapy. Arch Dis Child 70:F16-F18
Stenson BJ, Glover R, Parry G, Wilkie RA, Laing IA, Tarnow-Mordi WO (1994) Static respiratory compliance in the newborn III: early changes following surfactant therapy. Arch Dis Child 70:F19-F24
Thomson AH, Beardsmore CS, Silverman M (1985) The total compliance of the respiratory system during the first year of life. Bull Eur Physiopathol Respir 21:411–416
Haouzi P, Marchal F, Crance JP, Monin P, Vert P (1991) Respiratory mechanics in spontaneously breathing term and preterm neonates. Biol Neonate 60:350–360
Olinsky A, Bryan AC, Bryan MH (1976) A simple method of measuring total respiratory system compliance in newborn infants. S Afr Med J 50:128–130
Gappa M, Rabbette PS, Costeloe KL, Stocks J (1993) Assessment of passive respiratory compliance in healthy preterm infants: a critical evaluation. Pediatr Pulmonol 15:304–311
American Thoracic Society, European Respiratory Society (1993) Respiratory mechanics in infants: physiologic evaluation in health and disease. Am Rev Respir Dis 147:474–496
LeSouef PN, England SJ, Bryan AC (1984) Passive respiratory mechanics in newborns and children. Am Rev Respir Dis 129:552–556
Bland JM, Altman DJ (1986) Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement. Lancet I:307–310
Simbruner G, Coradello H, Lubec G, Pollak A, Salzer H (1982) Respiratory compliance of newborns after birth and its prognostic value for the course and outcome of respiratory disease. Respiration 43:414–423
Kelly E, Bryan H, Possmayer F, Frndova H, Bryan C (1993) Compliance of the respiratory system in newborn infants pre-and postsurfactant replacement therapy. Pediatr Pulmonol 15:225–230
Wilkie RA, Bryan MH (1987) Effect of bronchodilators on airway resistance in ventilator-dependent neonates with chronic lung disease. J Pediatr 111: 278–282
Balsan MJ, Jones JG, Watchko JF, Guthrie RD (1990) Measurements of pulmonary mechanics prior to the elective extubation of neonates. Pediatr Pulmonol 9:238–243
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
This work was conducted in the Simpson Memorial Maternity Pavilion in Edinburgh with suport from the Scottish Home and Health Department
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Stenson, B.J., Wilkie, R.A., Laing, I.A. et al. Reliability of clinical assessments of respiratory system compliance (Crs) made by junior doctors. Intensive Care Med 21, 257–260 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01701484
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01701484