eLetters

623 e-Letters

  • How a Belgian daily paper informed its readers about the contents of the review on waterbirth
    Sophie Alexander

    Le Soir, one of Belgium's leading French language newspapers (1), headlined the front page of its 23 May 2016 edition with "Birth in water: a dangerous new fashion." Page 6 was devoted to the review by Taylor et al; the subtitle said "New study underlines the dangers of drowning and pulmonary infection for babies; no benefit from this fashionable birthing technique". I was asked that afternoon, in my capacity of advise...

    Show More
  • Re: Handheld Doppler use for measuring newborn HR has been described in the literature
    Amanda Dyson

    We thank Dr Hutchon for his interest in our article and acknowledge his contribution to developing this technique of measuring heart rate rapidly and efficiently in newborns. We were particularly interested to hear of his experience with a Doppler that displays an averaged heart rate. We can see that having a displayed rather than counted Doppler heart rate would be highly practical in the delivery room providing that...

    Show More
  • Re:End of Life Decisions - Do we make them wisely?
    Praeksh S Shah

    Reply to End of Life Decisions - Do we make them wisely?: End of life decisions: How do we improve process? We thank Dr Cohn for his response to our paper and for voicing the issues it raised for him. Certainly one of the objectives of the study was to explore whether there were differences in approach to similar medical disorders in NICUs across Canada. We hoped that our finding of differences in what appear to be medical...

    Show More
  • Handheld Doppler use for measuring newborn HR has been described in the literature
    David J Hutchon

    We read this article with considerable interest as it confirms that Precordial Doppler Ultrasound (PDU) can detect the neonatal heart rate within seconds of birth, much earlier than is possible with oximetry and much more reliably than with auscultation. As the authors state "Handheld Doppler use for measuring newborn HR has been described in the literature" (by Goenka et al and by Hutchon) "but needs further investigat...

    Show More
  • Re: Water births: adverse events for the baby are rare but devastating
    Alastair Sutcliffe

    We are grateful for the interest in our paper and the opportunity to refute the suggestion that it is falsely reassuring. Our paper provides a fair and accurate representation of the best available data; it concludes that "this systematic review and meta-analysis did not identify definitive evidence that waterbirth causes harm to neonates ... However, there is currently insufficient evidence to conclude that there are no...

    Show More
  • Re: Current debate about the limit of viability: the neglected majority
    John Lantos

    Neonatal mortality in poor countries

    We appreciate Dr. Berger's astute observation that most of the babies in the world do not have access to neonatal intensive care. His statistics underestimate the extent of the problem. Around the world, 7 million infants die each year. Most die of diseases that are preventable or treatable. Their deaths are due to lack of access to the most basic medical care. This is no...

    Show More
  • Current debate about the limit of viability: the neglected majority
    Thomas M. Berger

    It is with great interest that I read the editorial entitled "Delivery room practices for extremely preterm infants: the harms of the gestational age label" by Janvier and Lantos (1) analysing the results of the EPIPAGE-2 study (2). The two authors question the appropriateness of the French non-intervention approach towards infants born at 22, 23 and 24 weeks for whom NICU admission was withheld in 96%, 91% and 38% of cas...

    Show More
  • Water births: adverse events for the baby are rare but devastating
    Mark W Davies

    The overall tone of this systematic review is to reassure the reader that waterbirths are safe; this is not justified by the results which rely almost exclusively on extremely poor quality retrospective cohort studies. Different study designs have significant differences in their susceptibility to bias and the authors have largely ignored this issue. Larger, non-randomised studies, more prone to bias, carry more weight ; n...

    Show More
  • Staffing in NICUs is more that a 1:1 nurse to patient ratio
    Kaye Spence

    I read the article by Watson et al and the accompanying Editorial. While it is an interesting concept to link nurse patient ratios with mortality this does not take into account the individual nurses and their experiences. I would challenge the authors to demonstrate how retrospective data measures acuity and nursing experience. The authors presented the 1:1 ratio as measured by the percentage of ICU days where there wa...

    Show More
  • The Dr Isaac 'Harry' Gosset Collection
    Andrew N Williams

    The 'Dr Isaac 'Harry' Gosset Collection' a repository of UK General Paediatric and Premature Baby Care 1947-1965 is now on line.

    http://www.northamptongeneral.nhs.uk/AboutUs/Ourhistory/Dr-Gosset/The -Dr-Isaac-Harry-Gosset-Collection.aspx

    Conflict of Interest:

    I am the author of the paper I am replying to

Pages