Article Text

PDF

Perinatal risk factors for neonatal encephalopathy: an unmatched case-control study
  1. Cally J Tann1,2,3,
  2. Margaret Nakakeeto4,5,
  3. Barbara A Willey6,
  4. Margaret Sewegaba2,5,
  5. Emily L Webb6,
  6. Ibby Oke7,
  7. Emmanuel Derek Mutuuza4,
  8. Donald Peebles3,
  9. Margaret Musoke4,
  10. Kathryn A Harris7,
  11. Neil J Sebire8,
  12. Nigel Klein8,
  13. Jennifer J Kurinczuk9,
  14. Alison M Elliott1,2,
  15. Nicola J Robertson3
  1. 1Clinical Research Department, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, UK
  2. 2MRC/UVRI Uganda Research Unit on AIDS, Entebbe, Uganda
  3. 3Institute for Women's Health, University College London, London, UK
  4. 4Neonatal Medicine, Mulago University Hospital, Kampala, Uganda
  5. 5Uganda Women's Health Initiative, Kampala, Uganda
  6. 6MRC Tropical Epidemiology Group, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, UK
  7. 7Department of Microbiology, Virology and Infection Prevention and Control, Great Ormond Street Hospital For Children NHS Trust, London, UK
  8. 8Institute for Child Health, University College London, London, UK
  9. 9National Perinatal Epidemiology Unit, Nuffield Department of Population Health, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
  1. Correspondence to Dr Cally J Tann, Clinical Research Department/MARCH Centre, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, Keppel Street, London, WC1E 7HT, UK; cally.tann{at}lshtm.ac.uk

Abstract

Objective Neonatal encephalopathy (NE) is the third leading cause of child mortality. Preclinical studies suggest infection and inflammation can sensitise or precondition the newborn brain to injury. This study examined perinatal risks factor for NE in Uganda.

Design Unmatched case–control study.

Setting Mulago National Referral Hospital, Kampala, Uganda.

Methods 210 term infants with NE and 409 unaffected term infants as controls were recruited over 13 months. Data were collected on preconception, antepartum and intrapartum exposures. Blood culture, species-specific bacterial real-time PCR, C reactive protein and placental histology for chorioamnionitis and funisitis identified maternal and early newborn infection and inflammation. Multivariable logistic regression examined associations with NE.

Results Neonatal bacteraemia (adjusted OR (aOR) 8.67 (95% CI 1.51 to 49.74), n=315) and histological funisitis (aOR 11.80 (95% CI 2.19 to 63.45), n=162) but not chorioamnionitis (aOR 3.20 (95% CI 0.66 to 15.52), n=162) were independent risk factors for NE. Among encephalopathic infants, neonatal case fatality was not significantly higher when exposed to early neonatal bacteraemia (OR 1.65 (95% CI 0.62 to 4.39), n=208). Intrapartum antibiotic use did not improve neonatal survival (p=0.826). After regression analysis, other identified perinatal risk factors (n=619) included hypertension in pregnancy (aOR 3.77), male infant (aOR 2.51), non-cephalic presentation (aOR 5.74), lack of fetal monitoring (aOR 2.75), augmentation (aOR 2.23), obstructed labour (aOR 3.8) and an acute intrapartum event (aOR 8.74).

Conclusions Perinatal infection and inflammation are independent risk factors for NE in this low-resource setting, supporting a role in the aetiological pathway of term brain injury. Intrapartum antibiotic administration did not mitigate against adverse outcomes. The importance of intrapartum risk factors in this sub-Saharan African setting is highlighted.

  • Neonatal Encephalopathy
  • Risk Factors
  • Uganda
  • Infection

This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt and build upon this work, for commercial use, provided the original work is properly cited. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Statistics from Altmetric.com

What is already known on this topic?

  • Perinatal brain injury is the third leading cause of child mortality globally, with some of the highest burden seen in low-resource African settings.

  • Preclinical studies suggest infection and inflammation can sensitise or precondition the term newborn brain to injury.

  • Understanding which perinatal risk factors are associated with neonatal encephalopathy is key to developing interventions to prevent newborn deaths and disability.

What this study adds?

  • Perinatal infection and inflammation are independent risk factors for neonatal encephalopathy in this African population, supporting a role in the aetiological pathway of term brain injury.

  • Intrapartum antibiotic use, however, was not associated with improved neonatal outcome.

  • The importance of other intrapartum risk factors in this setting is highlighted.

Introduction

Birth complications and perinatal infections are leading contributors to neonatal mortality globally.1 Each year, peripartum complications contribute to more than one million cases of neonatal encephalopathy (NE) and around half a million survivors with neurological impairment.2 In sub-Saharan Africa, where access to skilled birth attendants and emergency obstetric intervention is often limited, the contribution of peripartum hypoxic events to NE is likely very high.3 Across other settings, however, a number of peripartum risk factors for NE have been identified,4–7 supporting a complex multifactorial model of brain injury.

Increasing evidence suggests the critical importance of a sensitising effect of inflammation in the pathogenesis of NE.8 9 In neonatal rodent studies, exposure to bacterial endotoxin has been found to increase vulnerability of the developing brain to injury, with a pathway involving stimulation of toll-like receptors, inflammatory responses, chemotaxis and cell death.10 Other preclinical studies have shown a temporal relationship between bacterial endotoxin and brain injury, with both sensitising and preconditioning effects seen.11 12 In clinical studies, factors associated with perinatal infection such as maternal fever and prolonged rupture of membranes, are associated with NE5–7 10 13; however, this may be mediated by the direct effect of hyperthermia itself on the developing brain as opposed to any underlying cause.13 Few clinical studies have examined the role of specific perinatal infections and inflammation as independent risk factors for NE, although an important role is hypothesised.14

Understanding which perinatal risk factors are associated with NE is key in developing interventions to prevent newborn deaths and disability. Despite a high burden of NE in sub-Saharan Africa, the role of infectious comorbidity, such as neonatal bacteraemia and chorioamnionitis, and the contribution of other risk factors in the aetiology of NE have been poorly defined. We conducted an unmatched case–control study among hospital-born newborns in Uganda aiming to identify risk factors for NE in resource-limited settings.

Methods and materials

Setting

Uganda is a low-income country with a neonatal mortality rate of 23 per 1000 live births.15 Mulago National Referral Hospital, in the capital Kampala, receives high-risk pregnancies from the city and surrounding areas. In 2012, more than 33 000 deliveries occurred on the low-risk (21%) and high-risk (79%) labour wards. Fetal monitoring is by intermittent auscultation and women are not routinely examined at the start of second stage. Assisted deliveries (ventouse or forceps) are rarely performed. A fifth of deliveries are by caesarean section. Intravenous fluids, antibiotics and oxytocin are available. Neonatal resuscitation, performed by midwives, includes oxygen and bag-mask ventilation. Care on the 80-bed special care baby unit (SCBU) includes simple continuous positive airway pressure ventilation (not mechanical ventilation), intravenous fluids, antibiotics and antiseizure medication. Blood gas estimation facilities are not available.

Study design and recruitment

We conducted an unmatched case–control study between September 2011 and October 2012. Written informed parental consent was obtained. All term newborns admitted to the SCBU were examined for encephalopathy using the Thompson score.16 Cases were term newborns ≥37 weeks, with NE defined as a ‘Thompson score’ >5 within 12 hours of birth, as assessed by CJT or other study doctors. Neurological assessment was performed on recruitment for cases and controls and then daily for 5 days (cases only). Encephalopathy was graded (mild, moderate or severe) on the most severe day between days 1 and 5, per modified Sarnat classification,17 a scoring system used to grade the severity of hypoxic-ischaemic brain injury. Gestational age was assessed using last menstrual period or early obstetric ultrasound scan, and if unavailable based on external newborn examination.18 Infants were reviewed after discharge at 4–6 weeks of age to establish survival. Figure 1 describes how case and control infants moved through the study.

Figure 1

Diagram showing how infants moved through the study procedures. CRP, C reactive protein; qPCR, quantitative Polymerase Chain Reaction.

To reflect all hospital deliveries, controls were recruited in a ratio of 79:21 from the high-risk and low-risk wards, respectively. Control mothers and infants were systematically sampled from the labour ward admission book. Control infants were eligible for recruitment if term with Thompson score <3. Exclusion criteria (cases and controls) included prior antibiotics given to the infant (which would invalidate blood culture results), mother living >20 km from the hospital, out-born infants and no informed written consent. Infants with congenital abnormalities or other concomitant pathology were not excluded.

Data collection

Information from antepartum, intrapartum and postpartum periods was collected using structured maternal interviews and from clinical records. Postnatal anthropometric measurements on mother (height, weight) and newborns (occipitofrontal circumference, birth weight (SECA 336 electronic scales, Hamburg, Germany)) were taken.

Maternal and neonatal infection and inflammation

Maternal and neonatal blood was sampled at recruitment (<12 hours of delivery). Blood was stored at −80°C. Maternal and neonatal C reactive protein (CRP) was batch-tested (COBAS, Roche Diagnostics, Basel, Switzerland). Maternal HIV results were recorded from routine hospital testing.19

Blood culture and species-specific bacterial real-time PCR assays detected neonatal bacteraemia. Blood cultures (BACTEC) were performed for all case infants and for control infants with a clinical suspicion of sepsis. Isolated colonies were manually identified. Techniques for species-specific bacterial PCR and blood culture among the study cohorts have been published previously.20 Multiplexed PCR assays for the detection of bacteria considered pathogenic among newborns (group B Streptococcus, Pneumococcus, Staphylococcus aureus, group A streptococcus, Enterobacteriaceae sp) were performed on all cases and the first 101 control infants as a comparison group.20 CRP was measured as a marker of inflammation and presented according to centiles among control infants.

Placental pathology

Placentas are not routinely collected and stored at Mulago Hospital, and we aimed to collect, process and report placental histology in a quarter of cases and controls. Placentas were collected when infant resuscitation was required (Apgar score <6 at 5 min) and for identified potential controls. Whole placentas were fixed (10% formalin), sampled according to standard protocols and processed (SurgPath, Kampala). Slides were reported by an experienced perinatal pathologist (NJS) at the Camelia Botnar Laboratories, Great Ormond Street Hospital, blinded to outcome and all clinical information. Histological chorioamnionitis and funisitis were defined according to standard criteria.21

Statistical analysis

All data were coded (CJT), double-entered (MS Access) and analysed using Stata V.11.0. Univariable logistic regression was used to calculate crude ORs and 95% CIs to identify the independent effects of variables. A three-phase, causal approach to multivariable modelling was used to estimate adjusted ORs (aORs) using the conceptual framework described in figure 2.

Figure 2

Conceptual framework of preconception, antepartum and intrapartum factors used for the multivariable modelling of risk factors for neonatal encephalopathy (NE). A three-phase, causal approach to multivariable modelling, based on a conceptual framework, was used to estimate adjusted ORs. First, a model was constructed to include preconception and antepartum variables associated with NE during univariable analysis (p<0.05) or where there was strong a priori evidence or biological plausibility for an association. Second, intrapartum variables were added to the model to examine the effect on the associations seen between the antepartum and preconception factors and NE and to examine the effect of adjusting for these factors on the associations between NE and intrapartum factors. Finally, associations between perinatal infection and inflammation exposures and NE were adjusted for peripartum factors found to be independently associated with NE in the second phase of the modelling. Factors considered to be a probable consequence of events related to NE, but not themselves causative of NE, that is, emergency caesarean section, meconium-stained liquor and poor Apgar scores, were not included in multivariable models.

Since the proportion of missing data for variables was small (<5% for all variables, <1% for most variables), extra categories were created to represent missing values for the variables included. Inflammatory factors were defined as maternal CRP >90th centile, histological chorioamnionitis, histological funisitis, positive neonatal bacteraemia and raised neonatal CRP >97th centile. Population attributable fraction was calculated to assess the contribution of inflammatory factors to NE. The sample size of 210 cases and 409 controls ensured at least 80% power to detect risk factors conferring OR ≥2.5 at a significance level p<0.05, for main exposures with a prevalence of 5%–80%.

Results

During our 13-month recruitment period, 36 926 infants were born at Mulago Hospital, from which 210 encephalopathic and 409 control infants were recruited. Information on the number of babies who were considered as potential cases was not available due to the high number of babies admitted to the SCBU. For controls, a total of 505 mothers of term infants were identified by systemic sampling and approached. Of these 81% (409) consented to recruitment (figure 3).

Figure 3

Flow diagram of participants.

Table 1 shows the early clinical characteristics of case and control infants. External signs of a major congenital abnormality were uncommon but more frequent in cases (2.9% (6/210) vs 0.7% (3/408), respectively, p=0.037). Losses to follow-up at 4 weeks were 1.0% (2/210) of cases vs 3.2% (13/409) of controls (p=0.103). Neonatal case fatality (<28 days) was 33.7% (n=70, 95% CI 27.2% to 40.1%) among encephalopathic infants (table 1).

Table 1

Early clinical characteristics of case and control infants

Preconception, antepartum and intrapartum risk factors

In univariable analyses (table 2) case mothers were more likely to be primiparous, young, underweight and of short stature, to have severe anaemia or hypertension during pregnancy, and to be HIV-negative. Cases were more likely to be male, have a head circumference >97th centile and non-cephalic presentation. A third of encephalopathic infants were obstructed in labour compared with 8% of controls. Augmentation of labour, prolonged rupture of membranes, prolonged labour and meconium-stained liquor were all significantly more prevalent among cases. Acute intrapartum events were uncommon, but more prevalent among cases. No case infant was delivered by elective caesarean section. Fetal heart rate monitoring was significantly more prevalent among controls. In multivariable analysis one antepartum factor (hypertension in pregnancy), two infant factors (male sex, non-cephalic presentation) and four intrapartum factors (augmentation of labour, no fetal monitoring, acute intrapartum event and obstructed labour) were identified as independent risk factors for NE (table 2).

Table 2

Risk factors associated with neonatal encephalopathy in univariable analysis and after adjustment for preconception, antepartum and intrapartum factors

Perinatal infection/inflammation risk factors

The presence of neonatal bacteraemia was examined in 210 cases and 105 controls. For controls, quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) was performed among the first 101 recruits. In a further 4, qPCR and blood cultures were performed due to clinical concerns of early possible severe bacterial infection; all were negative. No significant differences were seen between control infants with and without bacteraemia results with respect to demographic or other baseline characteristics (data not shown). The prevalence of pathogenic bacterial species among infants with NE was 3.6%, 6.9% and 8.9%, with culture, PCR and both tests in combination, respectively.20 More encephalopathic infants than controls had pathogenic bacterial species detected (8.9% vs 2.0%, p=0.028) using culture and PCR in combination.20 PCR detected bacteraemia in 11 culture-negative encephalopathic infants (3 group B Streptococcus, 1 group A Streptococcus, 1 S. aureus and 6 Enterobacteriaceae (2 Enterobacter sp, 1 Pantoea sp, 1 Escherichia coli and 2 identified only as Enterobacteriaceae species)).20 Three case infants were negative on PCR but blood culture was positive for Saureus. Coagulase-negative staphylococcus was considered not pathogenic.

Placentas were processed and reported in 28.6% (60/210) of cases and 24.9% (102/409) of controls. No significant differences were seen between mothers with and without placental samples with respect to demographic or other baseline characteristics (data not shown). After adjustment for preconception, antepartum and intrapartum risk factors (detailed in table 3), several markers of infection or inflammation were found to be highly significant risk factors for NE, including neonatal bacteraemia, histological funisitis and raised maternal and early neonatal CRP (table 3).

Table 3

Univariable and adjusted analyses of perinatal infection/inflammation risk factors and between inflammatory and probable asphyxial factors

In NE, neonatal case fatality was not significantly higher for infants with early bacteraemia versus those without (44.4% (8/18) with bacteraemia vs 32.6%% (62/190) in those without, OR 1.65 (0.62–4.39), p=0.32). Intrapartum antibiotic was commonly used in cases and controls (17.8% (37/210) vs 14.0% (57/408), respectively, p=0.213). Among encephalopathic infants, intrapartum antibiotic use was not associated with improved neonatal survival (case fatality with intrapartum antibiotics 32.4% (12/37) vs 34.3% (58/169) without, p=0.826).

Discussion

Few studies have examined perinatal risk factors for NE in sub-Saharan Africa. In this Ugandan population, we found that maternal and newborn infection and inflammation, based on blood cultures, molecular assays and a subset of placentas, are independent risk factors for NE, with the strongest associations seen with fetal inflammation (funisitis) and early neonatal bacteraemia. Neonatal case fatality was not significantly higher for infants with NE exposed to neonatal bacteraemia. Intrapartum antibiotic use did not improve survival among encephalopathic infants. Other potentially modifiable antepartum and intrapartum risk factors were identified, with many antepartum factors mediated by intrapartum events suggesting potential large gains with improvements in intrapartum care.

In our study, funisitis, or infiltration of the umbilical cord with acute fetal inflammatory cells, was a significant risk factor for NE; however, the presence of membrane inflammation alone (isolated histological chorioamnionitis) was not. The reduced sample size of infants with placentas collected (n=162) may have been responsible for the lack of significance of the association seen between NE and chorioamnionitis; however, this smaller sample size retained more than 80% power to detect the associations seen for funisitis. Triggering of the fetal inflammatory responses, as evidenced by the presence of funisitis, has been associated previously with neurological impairment among both term and preterm infants.22–25 A high incidence of histological funisitis among infants with NE has been previously reported (22%–31%),24 26 with one retrospective observational study also finding funisitis to be significantly associated with encephalopathy (OR 9.29).24 A recent study from the Netherlands, examining associations between placental pathology and pattern of brain injury in NE, found a high incidence of histological chorioamnionitis across all patterns of brain injury, when compared with healthy term deliveries in a historic cohort from the same centre (50% vs 18%, respectively).26 The stronger associations with NE seen for histological funisitis, as opposed to chorioamnionitis, may imply that activation of the fetal inflammatory response is a key event, or that duration of exposure, or proximity of inflammation to the fetus, may be important.

Both a sensitising and preconditioning role of bacterial endotoxin on the effect of hypoxia-ischaemia on the immature brain have been seen in animal models, but supporting clinical data are limited. Our study provides evidence of an important role for early newborn bacteraemia in NE in humans, with an eightfold increase in odds of NE. Early neonatal infection did not significantly increase the odds of death among infants with NE, although the small numbers of infants in the infection-exposed group (n=18) may have reduced the ability to detect a true difference. Our findings are supported, however, by a US study, examining MRI in predicting outcome after NE, that reported a similar prevalence of sepsis and an increase in adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes, but not death, among encephalopathic infants with sepsis.27 Despite the administration of intrapartum antibiotics in almost a fifth of encephalopathy cases in our study, antibiotics did not improve survival. This lack of effect of antibiotic therapy is consistent with findings from the ORACLE trial, which examined neonatal outcomes after preterm rupture of membranes.28 29 Although our infants were not cooled, our incidence of sepsis was comparable to many hypothermia trials from high-income settings (5%–14%).30

Other studies from both low-income and high-income settings have examined this ‘dual hit’ hypothesis of infection and hypoxia-ischaemia. A population-based study from South Asia also reported significantly increased odds of early neonatal death due to intrapartum asphyxia in newborns exposed to prolonged rupture of membranes (aOR 1.52; 1.15–2.02),31 a predisposing factor for intrauterine infection and early newborn bacteraemia. Previous studies in high-income settings have shown a high prevalence of inflammatory indicators among infants with NE,32 and a combination of antenatal infection and a potentially birth-asphyxiating condition can dramatically increase the risk of cerebral palsy (OR 78.0) when compared with either alone.33 In our study, positive dose-related associations were seen between raised maternal and neonatal CRP, an acute phase reactant and NE. Previous studies have shown associations between a raised neonatal CRP and a number of neonatal condition including infection, perinatal asphyxia and meconium aspiration,34 and so an association with maternal and newborn infection cannot be assumed.

In univariable analysis, we identified several other peripartum risk factors for NE. Maternal and infant factors included primiparity, young maternal age, low maternal weight or stature, complications during pregnancy (hypertension, severe anaemia) and large infant head circumference. However, these antepartum factors did not significantly improve the fit of the data after adjustment for intrapartum events, suggesting that their association with NE is likely mediated by increasing the risk of intrapartum complication. However, even after adjustment, male infants and those of non-cephalic presentation remained significant risk factors for NE. Although an acute intrapartum event significantly increased the risk of NE, such events were uncommon, and other potentially modifiable factors such as hypertension in pregnancy, lack of fetal monitoring, non-cephalic presentation and obstructed labour contributed to a higher proportion of cases of NE in our population. A high demand for services in the face of low midwife to mother staffing ratios, lack of equipment and delays in providing rapid obstetric intervention may have been substantial contributing factors in our setting. Prioritising effective risk assessment and intrapartum care for women and babies delivering in healthcare facilities in low-resource settings has the potential to substantially reduce neonatal risk.35

There were limitations to this study. Placental sampling was performed in only a quarter of women, and although sampling appeared non-differential all bias cannot be excluded, and power to detect associations for placental variables was reduced. Recruitment of participants from a high-risk referral centre may explain the high rates of chorioamnionitis seen; however, this would have led to a conservative estimate of all ORs. Although we performed species-specific bacterial PCR in conjunction with neonatal blood culture to strengthen the diagnosis of neonatal bacteraemia, we still cannot exclude underdiagnosis. The majority of control infants did not show clinical signs of sepsis, and loss to follow-up rates in both groups were low. We cannot exclude all selection and recall bias, although rigorous verification with hospital records and comprehensive staff interview training aimed to minimise this.

In summary, perinatal infection and inflammation are independent risk factors for NE in this low-resource setting, supporting a role in the aetiological pathway of term brain injury. Intrapartum antibiotic administration did not mitigate again adverse outcomes. The importance of intrapartum risk factors in this sub-Saharan African setting is highlighted.

Acknowledgments

We thank the parents, guardians and children who participated in the study; the ABAaNA study team for their dedicated contribution to data collection and care of study participants; and Jamiir Mugalu, Jolly Nankunda, Natasha Nyombi, Flaviah Namiiro, Anita and all on the special care unit and labour ward at Mulago Hospital for their support. Thank you also to the MRC/UVRI Uganda Research Unit on AIDS, Entebbe and the Wellcome Bloomsbury Centre, LSHTM and the Camelia Botnar Laboratories at Great Ormond Street Hospital for their administrative and laboratory support.

References

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Contributors CJT, JJK, NK, NJS, DP, KAH, AME and NJR designed the study and were involved in data interpretation and report writing. CJT implemented and led the study. Data analysis was conducted by CJT and BAW, ELW and JJK provided statistical support. CJT, MN, MS, MM, NN, IO, EDM and PN participated in data collection. CJT, PN and KAH performed the molecular assays. MN, JM, AME and NJR provided logistical support. All authors reviewed and approved the final version. All authors had full access to all of the data (including statistical reports and tables) in the study and can take responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis. CJT affirms that the manuscript is an honest, accurate and transparent account of the study being reported; that no important aspects of the study have been omitted; and that any discrepancies from the study as planned have been explained.

  • Funding The study was funded by a Wellcome Trust Bloomsbury Clinical Fellowship in International Health to CT (094016/Z/10/Z). The Wellcome Trust had no role in the design and conduct of the study; collection, management, analysis and interpretation of the data; preparation, review or approval of the manuscript; and decision to submit the manuscript for publication.

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Ethics approval London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, Uganda Virus Research Institute and Uganda National Council of Science & Technology.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

  • Data sharing statement Data from this study will be made available for further research to anyone with an interest in relevant further study, subject to proper acknowledgements and on contacting the corresponding author.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.