Article Text

PDF

Follow up of fetal outcome in cases of maternal phenylketonuria in Northern Ireland
  1. A C Magee1,
  2. K Ryan2,
  3. A Moore3,
  4. E R Trimble2
  1. 1Regional Genetics Service, Belfast City Hospital Trust, Lisburn Road, Belfast BT9 7AB, Northern Ireland, UK
  2. 2Department of Clinical Biochemistry, Royal Group of Hospitals Trust, Falls Road, Belfast BT12 6BE
  3. 3Department of Dietetics, Royal Group of Hospitals Trust
  1. Correspondence to:
    Professor Trimble, Department of Clinical Biochemistry, Royal Group of Hospitals Trust, Falls Road, Belfast BT12 6BE, Northern Ireland, UK;
    e.trimble{at}quh.ac.uk

Abstract

Background: Maternal phenylketonuria (PKU) can result in multiple congenital anomalies. In Northern Ireland, the prevalence of PKU is relatively high at 1 in 4000.

Objective: To assess the outcome of 39 pregnancies in 20 mothers.

Results: Dietary control was established before conception in 17 pregnancies (44%). Five mothers with hyperphenylalaninaemia had 11 pregnancies. There were no congenital anomalies in this group, and all appear to be developing normally. Fifteen women with classical PKU had 28 pregnancies. One pregnancy ended in a first trimester miscarriage. Twelve out of 27 (44%) completed pregnancies produced babies with a congenital anomaly and/or developmental delay.

Conclusions: Most problems occurred when dietary control was not established until after the 2nd trimester. As the cohort of young women with treated PKU is growing steadily, maternal PKU is going to become an even greater cause for concern.

  • phenylketonuria
  • maternal
  • pregnancy
  • diet
  • PKU, phenylketonuria
  • HPA, hyperphenylalaninaemia
  • IQ, intelligence quotient

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Phenylketonuria (PKU) was first described by Asbjorn Folling in 1934.1 Treatment by dietary restriction of phenylalanine was introduced by Horst Bickel in 1953.2 Since then, the clinical challenge has become the management of pregnancy in the rapidly growing population of young women of childbearing age who have been treated for PKU from the neonatal period. Phenylalanine is teratogenic to the fetus,3 and there is a positive transplacental gradient for phenylalanine.4 It is now recognised that best practice is for the woman to have a very restricted protein diet and establish phenylalanine levels of < 250 μmol/l for at least two months before discontinuing reliable contraception.5,6 She should maintain this level of control throughout the pregnancy, with accurate measurement of phenylalanine levels at least once a week. As Northern Ireland has a high prevalence of PKU—1 in 40007 compared with the average of 1 in 10 000 in other white populations,8—the impact of maternal PKU is large. We therefore assessed the current status of maternal PKU in Northern Ireland (updating the previous report which examined pregnancy outcome up to 19939) and looked at the implications for future care of this group of patients.

METHODS

We reviewed all known pregnancies in women with hyperphenylalaninaemia (HPA) and PKU in Northern Ireland up to the end of December 2000. Maternal intelligence quotient (IQ) was determined from patient records. Dietary control was classified as achievement of phenylalanine levels of < 250 μmol/l before conception, during the first trimester, second trimester, third trimester, or not at all during the pregnancy. Pregnancy outcome was recorded as gestation, birth weight, head circumference, and the presence or absence of any congenital anomalies. Where appropriate, the IQ of the offspring was noted. Until recently, the Department of Health PKU register was active, and required the child’s IQ to be formally assessed (WISC) at age 8 years. Some younger children were assessed by the Griffiths, Stanford Binet, or Sheridan methods if there were concerns about development. In others, school performance was taken as an indicator of ability.

RESULTS

Five women with HPA had 11 pregnancies. All recorded phenylalanine levels were below 500 μmol/l. Maternal IQ was known in three mothers, who scored 96, 101, and 104. There were no congenital anomalies in this group. One child has classical PKU, and another has mild developmental delay.

Fifteen women with classical PKU had 28 pregnancies, one ending in a first trimester miscarriage. Maternal IQ was recorded for nine women and ranged from 73 to 102. No increase in prematurity or intrauterine growth retardation was noted. The outcome with regard to congenital anomaly is known in all 27 completed pregnancies. There is no information on development in four children. In two pregnancies, the outcome was stillbirth and anencephaly. Therefore developmental information is available for 21 of the cohort.

In seven women (11 pregnancies) dietary control was established before conception and continued throughout pregnancy. In this group, one child was stillborn and one had a congenital heart defect. No post mortem anomaly was found in the stillborn baby. One child has a borderline IQ.

In five women (seven pregnancies) dietary control was established in the first trimester of pregnancy. Three of these offspring have a congenital anomaly (anencephaly, unilateral talipes, and pyloric stenosis), but there is no evidence of mental retardation in the latter two.

Two women had their diet controlled in the second trimester; one infant had multiple anomalies and severe developmental delay, but chromosome analysis showed a deletion of 4p. It is not possible to assess which, if any, of this infant’s problems can be attributed to his mother’s PKU. She presented at 20 weeks gestation with no dietary control and a phenylalanine level of 652 μmol/l.

Another two women did not achieve control of their diet until the 3rd trimester; one child has marked microcephaly but is at mainstream school with normal development.

Three women (five pregnancies) never established dietary control. Four offspring have mild to moderate mental retardation, two are microcephalic, and one has congenital heart defects, gastroschisis, and subglottic stenosis. In the remaining pregnancy in this group, dietary control was attempted, but recorded levels ranged from 557 to 879 μmol/l.

In summary, 9/27(33%) of the offspring of mothers with classical PKU had a congenital anomaly. Where information is available about developmental outcome, 6/21 (29%) have some degree of delay. In all, 12 children have congenital anomaly and/or developmental delay. If we consider this as either a proportion of the 21 for which full information is available, or a proportion of all 27 pregnancies, the incidence of congenital anomaly and/or developmental delay is 44–57% (table 1).

Table 1

In 17 of the 39 pregnancies (44%), dietary control was established before conception.

DISCUSSION

Our results indicate an unacceptably high incidence of anomaly associated with maternal PKU. The few women with HPA and phenylalanine levels < 500 μmol/l do not present a major problem, but it must be noted that all needed a protein restricted diet before and during pregnancy. When the effects of maternal PKU were first recognised, reports indicated a risk of about 90% for mental retardation, 75% for microcephaly, 40–50% for intrauterine growth retardation, and 12–25% for congenital anomalies.10,11 It has even been suggested that surrogacy would provide a “safe haven” for the offspring of mothers with PKU.12

It is now evident that the best results for mothers with PKU are obtained when phenylalanine levels are controlled before and during pregnancy.13,14 However, ideal phenylalanine levels are not the whole answer. Tyrosine supplements may be necessary, and essential fatty acid intake must also be monitored. Some women find it difficult to maintain an adequate energy intake. These dietary regimens make huge demands not only on the woman but also on dietetic and medical personnel. One report has suggested that, in the space of one generation, the incidence of new cases of PKU related mental retardation could return to the former level.15 A recent report on maternal PKU, an international study covering 574 pregnancies in 382 hyperphenylalaninaemic mothers, identified an association of poor pregnancy outcome with mean maternal IQ < 83 and low socioeconomic status.16 In that report, dietary control was established before conception in 25.8% of pregnancies (44% in our group). We are concerned that the nationwide follow up of these children is no longer centralised because funding for the national PKU register has ceased. Information on the outcome of maternal PKU in the United Kingdom will now depend on each clinic organising individual monitoring. The work of the national PKU register allowed detailed documentation of congenital anomalies and also developmental assessments. We found that the mothers with PKU were reasonably keen to comply with this when they felt it was helpful to the PKU population in general. Perhaps it is time to reconsider the possible benefits of national guidelines, and the required infrastructure, for monitoring pregnancy outcome in this increasing population.

In Northern Ireland, we have details of 96 women with PKU who are of childbearing age (≥13 years) and a further five women with HPA. This predicts the need for a major input of education, support, and encouragement to minimise the incidence of PKU related handicap. We believe that this is an achievable goal of preventive medicine, and that these young women deserve the multidisciplinary help they need in order to plan their pregnancies and produce healthy babies.

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

Linked Articles

  • Fetal and Neonatal this issue
    Martin Ward Platt