Article Text

Visiting policies in neonatal intensive care units: staff and parents' views
  1. M CUTTINI
  1. Unit of Epidemiology
  2. Burlo Garofolo Children's Hospital
  3. Trieste, Italy
  4. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
  5. Udine, Italy
  6. Department of Pediatrics
  7. University of Padova, Italy
  8. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
  9. University of Modena, Italy
  10. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
  11. Lecco, Italy
  12. Department of Public Health
  13. University of Glasgow, Scotland
    1. V CHIANDOTTO
    1. Unit of Epidemiology
    2. Burlo Garofolo Children's Hospital
    3. Trieste, Italy
    4. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
    5. Udine, Italy
    6. Department of Pediatrics
    7. University of Padova, Italy
    8. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
    9. University of Modena, Italy
    10. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
    11. Lecco, Italy
    12. Department of Public Health
    13. University of Glasgow, Scotland
      1. B DALLA BARBA
      1. Unit of Epidemiology
      2. Burlo Garofolo Children's Hospital
      3. Trieste, Italy
      4. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
      5. Udine, Italy
      6. Department of Pediatrics
      7. University of Padova, Italy
      8. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
      9. University of Modena, Italy
      10. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
      11. Lecco, Italy
      12. Department of Public Health
      13. University of Glasgow, Scotland
        1. G B CAVAZZUTI
        1. Unit of Epidemiology
        2. Burlo Garofolo Children's Hospital
        3. Trieste, Italy
        4. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
        5. Udine, Italy
        6. Department of Pediatrics
        7. University of Padova, Italy
        8. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
        9. University of Modena, Italy
        10. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
        11. Lecco, Italy
        12. Department of Public Health
        13. University of Glasgow, Scotland
          1. R ZANINI
          1. Unit of Epidemiology
          2. Burlo Garofolo Children's Hospital
          3. Trieste, Italy
          4. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
          5. Udine, Italy
          6. Department of Pediatrics
          7. University of Padova, Italy
          8. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
          9. University of Modena, Italy
          10. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
          11. Lecco, Italy
          12. Department of Public Health
          13. University of Glasgow, Scotland
            1. M REID
            1. Unit of Epidemiology
            2. Burlo Garofolo Children's Hospital
            3. Trieste, Italy
            4. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
            5. Udine, Italy
            6. Department of Pediatrics
            7. University of Padova, Italy
            8. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
            9. University of Modena, Italy
            10. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
            11. Lecco, Italy
            12. Department of Public Health
            13. University of Glasgow, Scotland

              Statistics from Altmetric.com

              Editor—Findings from a study carried out in Italy as part of an international project on parental visiting1 may provide additional information in response to the points raised by Dr Harvey in his thoughtful commentary to our recent paper.2 Three third level neonatal intensive care units (NICUs) with an open (that is 24 hours a day) policy towards parental visiting were compared with two units restricting visiting to specified hours (“restricted” policy). Sixty doctors, 106 nurses, and parents of 80 consecutively admitted very low birthweight babies were interviewed.

              The staff views are strikingly consistent with their unit policy (table1), with doctors and nurses in units that restrict parental visiting being less convinced about its value, and more fearful of interference with everyday routines.

              Table 1

              Staff and parental views on NICU visiting policies

              Most mothers would like to be able to visit more; however, only in the two restricted policy units are hospital regulations felt to be the major limiting factor.

              The over threefold higher proportion of babies fed with maternal milk at four weeks in the open policy NICUs cannot be accounted for by a number of potential confounding variables, either related to the baby or to the mother.3

              Patterns of counselling appear not so much linked with unit policies, as with parental role. A total of 42% of fathers received the first communication about their baby's conditionwithin one hour from delivery, and 10% later than 24 hours. The corresponding figures for mothers are 21% and 25% respectively, with no difference between inborn and outborn babies. Over 90% of fathers were directly informed by a doctor, whereas 41% of mothers were informed by their partner. In accompanying comments, many women expressed discomfort, and asked for earlier, first hand communication from the doctor in charge of their baby.

              Almost a decade divides this study from the EURONIC survey,1 but the high proportion of NICUs still restricting parental visiting in some countries shows that these findings are still relevant. As Dr Harvey rightly points out, education of staff and parents is needed to stimulate change.

              References

              View Abstract

              Request permissions

              If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.