Article Text

PDF

Association between blood lactate and acid-base status and mortality in ventilated babies
  1. S A Deshpande,
  2. M P Ward Platt
  1. Newcastle Neonatal Service, Special Care Baby Unit, Royal Victoria Infirmary, Newcastle upon Tyne
  1. Dr Deshpande, Department of Neonatology, Royal Shrewsbury NHS Trust, Shrewsbury SY3 8XQ

Abstract

AIM To investigate the relation between common acid-base parameters and blood lactate concentrations and their prognostic importance in sick, ventilated neonates.

METHODS Two hundred and seventy eight serial simultaneous measurements of arterial acid-base status and blood lactate concentrations were carried out in 75 mechanically ventilated neonates with indwelling arterial catheters (gestational age and birthweight, median (range) - 29 (23-40) weeks, and 1340 (550-4080) g, respectively).

RESULTS There were no correlations between arterial blood lactate and pH and base excess within subjects (r=0.07 and r= -0.06, respectively) and only weakly positive but clinically irrelevant positive correlations between subjects (r=0.28 and r=0.27) in this group. Even in those infants who had not received any bicarbonate before their initial measurements (n=48), there were no correlations between initial blood lactate concentrations and pH (r=0.27), base excess (r=0.17), or serum bicarbonate concentrations (r=-0.18). There was no relation between peak lactate concentration (PLC) and base excess (r=0.16), and only a weak correlation between peak lactate concentration (PLC) and pH (r=0.28). Negative base excess was an insensitive indicator of raised lactate concentrations. Only two out of 33 (6%) instances of hyperlactataemia (lactate >2.5 mmol/l) would have been identified with a base excess <-10 mmol/l as a cutoff. Lower cutoff values of base excess or pH performed no better. Raised lactate concentrations were associated with increased mortality at all levels. While six of 53 (11%) infants with a PLC <2.5 mmol/l died, this proportion increased to four of 15 (27%) with a PLC between 2.5-5.0 mmol/l, and four of seven (57%) with a PLC >5.0 mmol/l. Infants showing little rise or a substantial fall in blood lactate fared better than those with persistently raised values. A clinically important increase in blood lactate preceded the development of clinical markers of deterioration and complications in six infants.

CONCLUSIONS Contrary to popular belief, pH or base excess cannot be used as proxy measures for blood lactate concentration, and independent measurements of the latter are needed. Blood lactate concentrations may provide an early warning signal and important prognostic information in ill, ventilated neonates. In this regard, serial measurements of blood lactate are more useful than a single value.

  • blood lactate
  • base excess
  • pH
  • neonatal intensive care.

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Hypoxia and hypotension are common in sick neonates, particularly preterm infants receiving intensive care. Monitoring of tissue perfusion is essential for early recognition of circulatory failure, institution of appropriate treatment, and in assessing response. Changes in heart rate, blood pressure, skin perfusion and urine output, which are generally used to detect tissue malperfusion in this age group, are insensitive markers as clinically relevant cellular hypoxia and malperfusion may be present well before clinically apparent changes in cardiovascular responses are seen. The size of these infants has generally precluded the use of more invasive haemodynamic monitoring, such as pulmonary artery thermodilution catheters to measure cardiac output, mixed venous oxygen saturations, and oxygen delivery.

Measurement of blood lactate concentrations is another tool used in critically ill adults for assessing tissue perfusion. With a critical reduction in oxygen and substrate delivery, aerobic metabolism through the Kreb’s cycle cannot be sustained, and tissues increasingly need anaerobic metabolism to meet their energy needs. This, in turn, results in increased production and accumulation of blood lactate. Studies in experimental animals and critically ill adults have shown that the degree of increase in blood lactate is proportional to the severity of oxygen deficiency and the decrease in oxygen delivery.1 2Blood lactate concentrations in critically ill and injured adult patients can be used to detect tissue hypoxia at an early stage, assess illness severity, and predict outcome.3-6 Serial measurements of blood lactate concentrations are more valuable than a single measurement, not only in providing a more precise assessment of prognosis, but also in evaluating response to treatment.7

Despite this volume of information on the value of blood lactate measurement in ill adults, information on its importance in critically ill neonates is limited. Hyperlactataemia is associated with increased mortality in premature infants with respiratory distress syndrome,8 9 and in term infants with severe respiratory failure receiving extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO).10 Increased lactate concentrations in preterm infants have also been reported to be early indicators of sepsis11 and the need for blood transfusions.12 13 In clinical practice, presence of acidosis, and in particular, negative base excess (“base deficit”) is commonly assumed to reflect impaired tissue perfusion and hyperlactataemia. However, we could find no published evidence to support this, and studies of adult patients have shown either no correlations between acid-base status and blood lactate,14 15 or significant but clinically unimportant correlations between them.16 Despite this, pH and base excess continue to be used as proxy measures for tissue perfusion in neonates, and both therapeutic interventions and illness severity scores are based on these measurements.17

This study examines the relation between pH and negative base excess with arterial blood lactate concentrations in a population of mechanically ventilated neonates.

Methods

Ethical approval for the study was granted by the Joint Ethics Committee of Newcastle Health Authority and the University of Newcastle upon Tyne.

We prospectively studied serial arterial acid-base status and blood lactate concentrations in 75 consecutive sick, ventilated neonates with indwelling arterial lines, who had been admitted to the neonatal intensive care units in Newcastle upon Tyne. Their median (range) gestational age was 29 (23-40) weeks and birthweight 1340 (550-4080) g. There were 41 boys and 34 girls. Twenty four infants were less than 28 weeks of gestational age while 18 babies weighed less than 1000 g at birth. Forty six babies needed intermittent positive pressure ventilation for resuscitation. Surfactant deficiency respiratory distress syndrome (RDS) was the commonest reason for ventilation (n=60), followed by persistent pulmonary hypertension (n=4), prematurity (n=3), group B streptococcal pneumonia (n=3), congenital malformations of the respiratory tract (n=3) and recurrent apnoea and asphyxia (one each). All these infants received intravenous 10% glucose infusions, with the total fluid intake varying between 100-165 ml/kg/day. None of these infants received intravenous amino acid solution, lipid emulsion, or lactate containing fluids during the study period. No attempt was made to control the administration of volume expanders such as 4.5% human albumin and/or packed cell transfusions, inotropes, or alkali. The results of blood lactate measurement were not available to the clinical team during the study period.

Blood samples were collected from indwelling arterial catheters at approximately 12 hourly intervals for a maximum of five serial measurements per baby. The study was terminated early in the event of death or removal of the arterial catheter either due to complications or a substantial improvement in the infant’s status. Blood gas determinations were carried out using AVL-995 (AVL Medical Instruments UK Ltd, Staffs) and Corning 178 (Ciba Corning Diagnostics Ltd, Essex) pH/blood gas analysers.

At each of these blood gas determinations, 40 μl of the residual blood from the syringe were collected in a volumetric microcapillary tube containing heparin and immediately placed into a tube containing 200 μl of chilled 5% perchloric acid. The samples were immediately separated and the supernatant fluid frozen at -80°C pending analysis. Whole blood lactate concentrations were measured using a microenzymatic lactate dehydrogenase method with a Cobas Bio fast centrifugal analyser.18 The intra-assay and interassay standard deviations (coefficients of variation) for the lactate assay were 0.016 (5.6%) and 0.026 (7.7%), respectively. Samples from each subject were run in a single assay, thereby avoiding interbatch variation in an individual subject.

For the purposes of this study, hyperlactataemia was defined as an arterial blood lactate concentration of greater than 2.5 mmol/l. Data were analysed using the MINITAB statistical package (Clecom, Birmingham). The relation between acid-base parameters (pH and base excess) and blood lactate concentrations was studied between subjects (with the mean blood lactate concentrations for each subject in both groups) and within subjects (by calculating the residuals for each measurement from the mean for that subject). Peak lactate concentrations between various groups were compared using Student’st test after logarithmic transformation. Pearson’s correlation coefficients were used to define the relation between acid-base parameters and blood lactate concentrations. As the base excess values were not normally distributed and they could not be log transformed, Spearman’s rank test was used to evaluate their relation with blood lactate values. Fisher’s exact test was used to study the association between acid-base parameters and blood lactate with outcome.

Results

A total of 278 simultaneous measurements of arterial acid-base parameters and blood lactate were obtained from these 75 neonates. The initial sample was obtained at a median (range) age of 20 (1-68) hours after birth. In all but seven infants the first study sample was obtained more than eight hours after birth, reflecting the high proportion of outborn babies being transferred into the units.

There was no correlation between common acid-base parameters such as pH, base excess, bicarbonate concentrations and blood lactate concentrations (fig 1). Neither pH nor base excess showed any association with blood lactate concentrations within subjects (r=0.075 and r= -0.063 respectively; P>0.2). There was a weakly positive intersubjects correlation between blood lactate and pH (r=0.284; P<0.02) and base excess (r=0.272; P=0.04). This is, however, contrary to the expected negative correlation between these acid-base parameters and blood lactate concentrations. There was a significant but probably clinically irrelevant weakly positive correlation between PLC and concurrent pH (r=0.279; P<0.05). We could not find any correlation between PLC and base excess (r=0.162; P>0.2).

Figure 1

Correlations of arterial blood pH and base excess with blood lactate concentrations    

Forty eight infants did not receive any alkali treatment before their first study sample was taken. Even in these infants, there were no correlations between initial blood lactate concentrations and pH (r=0.269; P>0.05), base excess (r=0.169; P>0.2), or serum bicarbonate concentrations (r=-0.179; P>0.2). In the remaining 27 infants in whom initial acid-base and lactate measurements were obtained after administration of bicarbonate, there were positive correlations between blood lactate with base excess and bicarbonate concentrations (r=0.511; P<0.02 and r=0.405; P<0.05, respectively) but none with pH (r=0.251; P>0.2).

Twenty two (29%) neonates had hyperlactataemia, defined as arterial blood lactate concentration in excess of 2.5 mmol/l. Neither pH nor base excess were sensitive indicators of hyperlactataemia. With a base excess less than -10 mmol/l as a cutoff, only two of 33 (6%) instances of hyperlactataemia would have been identified. Even changing this cutoff value to -8 or -5 mmol/l did not significantly improve the detection of hyperlactataemia. Low pH performed no better. Using a pH ≼7.20 as a criterion of significant acidosis, 30 of 33 (91%) of instances of hyperlactataemia would not have been identified. In all three instances of blood lactate concentrations ≽10 mmol/l, neither pH nor base excess were abnormal.

Fifteen (20%) infants died during their hospital stay. Raised blood lactate concentrations but neither the lowest pH nor the worst base excess were associated with increased inpatient mortality (fig 2). The inpatient mortality was 11% (6/53) with PLC ≼2.5 mmol/l and increased with increasing PLC, being 27% (4/15) when PLC was 2.501-5.0 mmol/l, and 57% (4/7) when PLC >5.0 mmol/l; both infants with PLC ≽10 mmol/l died in the early neonatal period.

Figure 2

Inpatient mortality in relation to the lowest pH (7.1; P*=0.716), worst base excess (-10 mmol/l; P*=0.734), and peak blood lactate concentrations (5 mmol/l; P*=0.026) * Fisher’s exact test

Not all infants with hyperlactataemia died. Serial measurements of blood lactate were available in 66 infants. Of 49 who never became hyperlactataemic, only four infants died. Of 12 infants who had persistently high or continuously rising blood lactate, nine died. Infants showing a consistent decrease or only a modest increase in blood lactate concentrations during the study period generally did well. This was true even of those infants with initial hyperlactataemia. The subsequent change in blood lactate concentration, once it had exceeded a value of 2.5 mmol/l, was also useful in differentiating survivors from non-survivors. Having reached a value of >2.5 mmol/l, the subsequent median (range) per cent change in survivors was -44.73% (-32.2 to -65.1) while that in non-survivors was -7.22% (-17.5 to +0.9), (P=0.008; 95% CI=30.06-54.23) (fig 3). In six infants a rise in blood lactate concentrations preceded the clinical development of a complication such as hypotension (n=4), necrotising enterocolitis (n=1), or renal failure (n=1).

Figure 3

Per cent reduction in blood lactate concentrations in survivors and non-survivors after becoming hyperlactataemic ( blood lactate > 2.5 mmol/l) Median value for each group shown. Mann-Whitney U test showed that the two groups were significantly different from each other (P=0.008).

Six infants had evidence of persistent pulmonary hypertension. All these infants were treated with a similar protocol, consisting of volume expansion, inotropic support with dobutamine, pulmonary arterial vasodilatation with tolazoline, hyperventilation and alkalisation. None of these infants received ECMO support, although three of them entered an ongoing trial of ECMO. Blood lactate concentrations in the non-survivors from this group were greater than 5.0 mmol/l and seemed to be useful indicators of outcome (table 1).

Table 1

Ventilatory and oxygenation indices and blood lactate concentrations and in infants with persistent pulmonary hypertension

Discussion

This was an observational study on a selected population of infants. Only those ventilated infants with indwelling arterial lines were chosen, as the volume of blood needed for measurement of lactate (40 μl) is generally present as residue in the syringe after blood gas determination. Thus there was no penalty to the baby in terms of extra blood loss for the study. Moreover, although good correlations have been shown between arterial blood lactate and mixed, central, and peripheral venous blood lactate concentrations,19-21 data on the use of capillary blood lactate as an alternative to arterial blood lactate are relatively sparse. Thus we chose not to include ventilated infants who did not have an indwelling arterial catheter. For obvious ethical reasons, it was not possible to define the normal ranges of arterial blood lactate concentrations in healthy infants. Previous studies of blood lactate concentrations in the umbilical arterial blood of healthy term and preterm infants show that most values are less than 2.5 mmol/l beyond the first six hours after birth.22 23 Moreover, blood lactate concentrations above 2 mmol/l are unusual in normal adults as well as non-hypotensive general ward patients24 ; concentrations below this are generally considered normal in critically ill adults.25 A striking increase in mortality was shown in critically ill adults as blood lactate concentration increased >2.5 mmol/l.26 Thus it seems reasonable to use blood lactate concentrations greater than 2.5 mmol/l to define hyperlactataemia in neonates. We did not control the administration of alkalinising agents, volume expanders, and inotropes in this study. However, these interventions were not influenced by the blood lactate concentrations because these were unknown to the clinicians treating these infants.

Presence of metabolic acidosis (negative base excess) is often assumed to reflect inadequate tissue perfusion and oxygenation. The main purpose of our study was to examine the relation between common acid-base parameters and blood lactate concentrations, another indicator of tissue perfusion, in critically ill neonates. Tissue perfusion and oxygenation is a complex process mediated through a balance between oxygen delivery and consumption. Under physiological conditions, oxygen consumption is effected mainly through changes in the oxygen extraction. When oxygen extraction reaches the maximal value, oxygen delivery becomes critical in sustaining aerobic metabolism. Further reductions in oxygen delivery result in cellular oxygen deficit, and tissues switch to anaerobic glycolysis to meet their energy needs with increased production of lactate. Liver and, to a lesser extent, kidneys metabolise lactate through both oxidative and non-oxidative (mainly, gluconeogenesis) routes. Accumulation of blood lactate, therefore, occurs when increased production overwhelms the clearance mechanisms of this ion. Hyperlactataemia in circulatory failure is thus a rather late phenomenon that happens when oxygen extraction is near maximal and critical tissue hypoxia has occurred. In this respect changes in oxygen extraction and delivery are more sensitive markers of tissue hypoperfusion. However, these require measurement of parameters such as mixed venous oxygen saturation and cardiac output which are technically difficult in small sick neonates, and, therefore, markers of tissue hypoperfusion such as lactate have to be relied on in this population.

It has been suggested that in acute lactic acidosis the blood lactate concentration and base excess correlate well.27 In our study, however, we could not show any clinically relevant relation between common acid-base parameters, such as pH and negative base excess, and arterial blood lactate concentrations. These results agree with the observations in adults.14 15 28 Cheung and others also could not find any significant linear relation between plasma lactate and arterial pH or serum bicarbonate values in infants referred for ECMO.10 This is an important finding for two reasons. First, the presence of negative base excess, which is generally relied on to detect inadequate tissue perfusion, cannot be used as a proxy for blood lactate concentrations. Hence studies of interventions designed to improve tissue perfusion, such as the use of volume expanders or comparative trials of various inotropic agents, should include measurement of blood lactate as a marker of tissue perfusion. Second, although many babies in our study had their negative base excess corrected by the administration of alkali, their blood lactate continued to be high or rose. Thus correction of negative base excess may actually mask the continuing tissue malperfusion, and reliance on this parameter alone may provide a false reassurance of cellular wellbeing.

This lack of a relation between blood lactate and base excess may be due to several possible reasons. In most instances of hyperlactataemia, the arterial acid-base parameters were within normal range. Normalisation of pH through the administration of alkali is possibly the most important factor. However, this discrepancy between blood lactate concentrations and arterial pH, base excess, and bicarbonate concentrations was also seen in infants prior to receiving any bicarbonate. There was a significant positive correlation of blood lactate with serum bicarbonate concentrations among infants who had received bicarbonate before their first study measurement. Alkalosis, particularly respiratory in origin, stimulates the rate limiting enzyme of glycolysis—phosphofructokinase, resulting in increased lactate production.29 30 Presence of hepatic dysfunction or sepsis may also produce alkalosis in the presence of hyperlactataemia,31 although none of our patients had any evidence of liver dysfunction and only three infants had sepsis. Conversely, only in 9% of instances when arterial pH was less than 7.20 or in only 12% of instances of base excess <-10 mmol/l, was the blood lactate greater than 2.5 mmol/l. The metabolic acidosis in these instances may be related to the accumulation of unmeasured anions not related to lactate metabolism,32 the movement of circulating lactate into tissues by acidaemia,33 and the limited ability of the preterm kidney to excrete H+ and ammonium ions, a lower renal threshold for bicarbonate, and reduced availability in the urine of titratable acid, specifically phosphate.34

During anaerobic glycolysis, glucose is metabolised to lactate without any change in the hydrogen ion (H+) concentration (glucose +2ADP + 2Pi ➞ 2lactate + 2ATP+ 2H2O, where ADP is adenosine diphosphate, Pi is inorganic phosphate, and ATP is adenosine triphosphate). Hydrogen ions are produced during hydrolysis of ATP by tissues (ATP + H2O ➞ ADP + Pi + H+). Under anaerobic conditions, tisssues are unable to synthesise ATP from ADP and Pi, resulting in accumulation of hydrogen ions. Thus protons are generated not though the production of lactate but through the hydrolysis of ATP35 36 and it is possible to have a selective increase in glycolysis without excessive hydrolysis of ATP.37 There is also some evidence that the lactate and hydrogen ions are transported out of muscle at different rates.38 Thus lactate ions may be generated without corresponding proton generation.

Mechanisms exist to protect the intracellular pH such that substantial systemic acidosis produces concomitant inhibition of phosphofructokinase in peripheral glycolytic tissues such as skeletal muscle.29 This may mask the hepatic underextraction and clearance of lactate, thereby producing normal blood lactate concentration. Irrespective of the possible underlying mechanism(s) of these discrepancies, it is clear that measurement of base excess cannot be relied on as a proxy measure of blood lactate concentration.

The question then arises, is the measurement of blood lactate of value in sick neonates ? Although our study was not primarily designed to evaluate the prognostic importance of blood lactate concentrations in neonates, we did find an increased inpatient mortality associated with increasing blood lactate concentrations in this selected population. In many instances, blood lactate concentrations rose before any deterioration in the infant’s condition had become clinically apparent. Changes in arterial pH and/or base excess were not informative of the subsequent outcome. In this regard, measurement of blood lactate concentrations, especially serially, may give important prognostic information and an early warning signal. We emphasise the selected nature of our population—that is, only those infants with an indwelling arterial lines were studied.

An early study of the value of blood lactate measurement in RDS showed an inverse relation between blood lactate and the severity of RDS with the lowest lactate values found in infants dying of RDS.9In 1972 Beca and Scopes studied blood lactate and acid-base status in 21 preterm infants with RDS.8 Although these babies were relatively more mature and larger than in our study, their findings were strikingly similar to ours. They showed that serial blood lactate measurements were more valuable than a single value, and that babies whose blood lactate concentrations remained low, or fell rapidly, were more likely to survive. Thus in spite of the rapid strides in neonatal intensive care over more than 20 years, the measurement of blood lactate remains a potentially important tool for identifying infants at particularly high risk of death. However, Beca and Scopes claimed that low pH was a reasonable proxy for hyperlactataemia: our data clearly refute this.

We observed that raised blood lactate concentrations seemed to precede clinical deterioration in six babies, although this was not the aim of our study. Fitzgerald et al, investigating infected preterm babies, found substantially increased blood lactate concentrations in these infants, and suggested that these increases were early markers of sepsis.11 The mechanism of hyperlactataemia in sepsis is different to that in RDS, being related to limited oxygen extraction resulting from maldistribution of microcirculatory flow, but these observations emphasise the value of blood lactate concentration as an indicator of a baby’s wellbeing under a variety of circumstances. Recently, admission and peak plasma lactate concentrations of 15 mmol/l or greater in near term or term infants referred for ECMO have been shown to predict both mortality10 and subsequent neurodevelopmental outcome.39 The association between increased lactate and higher mortality in our mainly preterm neonatal population complements these findings.

Recently, normal ranges have been established for capillary blood lactate concentrations in healthy preterm and term infants.40 41 Furthermore, capillary blood lactate concentrations differ little from arterial concentrations in ill neonates.42 This would allow capillary blood samples to be used extensively for blood lactate measurements in ill infants.

Acknowledgments

Dr Deshpande was supported by the Scientific and Research Committee of Newcastle Health Authority and by the Foundation for the Study of Infant Deaths.

References

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.